Skip navigation
best and worst alternative investments Roy Scott/Getty Images

Shift From Active to Passive Approaches Tipping Point in 2019

If the current trend holds, ETFs will surpass mutual funds and top 50 percent of assets in 2019.

By Charles Stein

(Bloomberg) --A line between active and passive funds is set to cross next year.

When it comes to mutual funds and exchange-traded funds that buy U.S. stocks, those that passively track indexes now hold 48 percent of assets, according to estimates from Morningstar Inc. They’ll top 50 percent in 2019 if the current trend holds.

That would mark a tipping point for the investing industry, which for decades built its stature on the prowess of stock-and-bond pickers seeking to beat the markets. In recent years, investors have ditched those active managers in favor of ETFs and other index funds, which typically offer a way to get market exposure at far lower fees. The shift continued this year even as the benchmarks the passive funds follow wobbled and fell.

“I’d expect the trend from active to passive to continue,” said Benjamin Phillips, a consultant with Casey Quirk. “It’s not simply investors grabbing the tail of the bull -- it’s a secular shift in how advisers are building portfolios.”

Passively managed U.S. stock funds increased their market share to 48.1 percent as of Nov. 30 from 45.7 percent a year earlier, Morningstar data show.

Beyond U.S. equities, the power balance tilted broadly to index funds in 2018. The move was less pronounced in bonds, where money managers have more consistently outperformed their benchmarks. Investors pulled an estimated $150 billion in the first 11 months of the year from actively run funds across asset classes, excluding money markets. In contrast, they added $395 billion to passive funds, according to Morningstar.

Sharp Divide

The divide was especially dramatic in November as market volatility picked up. Active funds lost more than $50 billion to redemptions while index funds took in a similar amount.

Mutual fund outflows could accelerate if investors cashing out amid recent volatility choose to use ETFs when they reinvest.

“Active mutual fund investors have a history of panicking when things get tough,” said Eric Balchunas, senior analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence. “You tend to see passive gain market share in difficult environments.”

It isn’t all positive for passive funds in 2018. While they added market share, their flows will fall well short of 2017’s record of almost $700 billion in contributions.

Here’s a look at how the biggest fund companies are faring:

Vanguard Group

  • The company, which started the first index mutual fund for individual investors in 1976, brought in an estimated $168 billion through November in passive funds, Morningstar estimates show. That compares with $329 billion for all of 2017.
  • The Valley Forge, Pennsylvania-based firm is feeling the impact of diminished flows to ETFs, which are on pace to attract just over $300 billion industrywide, versus $467 billion last year.
  • Still, Vanguard is likely to post higher 2018 inflows than any of its rivals.


  • The New York-based firm saw passive inflows of $108 billion through November, per Morningstar’s estimate. In 2017, they were $213 billion. The pace picked up in November when the firm attracted more than $25 billion to its U.S. ETFs -- a record monthly haul for the company.
  • The world’s largest ETF provider has seen the steepest drop in some of its heavily traded funds that are most sensitive to stock movements.


  • The firm saw an increase to its passive products in 2018, gathering $64 billion through November, as estimated by Morningstar, compared with $52 billion for 2017.
  • In August, the Boston-based fund giant introduced the industry’s first zero-fee index mutual funds and cut prices across much of its passive lineup. Explaining her firm’s newfound commitment to passive products, Chief Executive Officer Abigail Johnson said in an October interview, “If we decide to do something I want to be really good at it.”
  • On the active side, the firm saw $17 billion in outflows, Morningstar estimates. Yet that’s good news since altogether Fidelity’s stock and bond pickers could end up with the smallest annual outflow since 2014.

American Funds

  • The Los Angeles company continues to buck the trend by attracting money to its active funds. It added $21.4 billion through November, ahead of last year’s total of $16.6 billion, according to Morningstar.
  • Most of the money has flowed to the company’s target-date retirement funds, which have been gaining market share in recent years.

    --With assistance from Annie Massa and Rachel Evans.To contact the reporter on this story: Charles Stein in Boston at [email protected] To contact the editors responsible for this story: Margaret Collins at [email protected] Josh Friedman, Alan Mirabella


TAGS: Mutual Funds
Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.