Skip navigation

DFA Funds

or Register to post new content in the forum

42 RepliesJump to last post

 

Comments

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Dec 10, 2008 4:39 pm

Yeah except the design and that 1% outperformance only worked for a few years, they seem to be lagging everything real bad.

Dec 10, 2008 5:14 pm

I’m still using Symmetry (a portfolio builder of DFA funds). They are doing ok. Through November, their 100% equity portfolio is still beating the S&P (including my 1% fee and the custodian’s .2% fee) for their 5 and 10 year numbers.  The 1 and 3 yr numbers are lagging, but they have never claimed to beat the market in the short term (or in the long term for that matter).

  I just like the way they invest.  I have clients who have been burned this year by Van Kampen, who decided to dump energy stocks about two years ago, and go heavy on financials about a year ago. I'm tired of managers trying to pick which sectors to overweight/underweight, which is why I like Symmetry and DFA. They don't guess based on market factors, they just stay the course.
Dec 10, 2008 7:22 pm

They just got burned by Van Kampen this year??? They have been hanging on for dear life with both hands for a lot of years based off their internet number(Anyone remember VanKampen Strategic Growth??- Fund got so bad they closed it xfered assets to another fund and renamed that one too.)

  Why not look into UITs(not van kampens, try first trust). Essentially they are little quant strategies.  
Dec 13, 2008 9:29 pm

The thing about DFA, is that they expect you to push the Buy & Hold strategy, which is certainly working well in this market…if you’re looking for more losses. I got the impression that if there were too many redemptions by me, the RIA, that they’d unapprove me for their funds. - Based on that attitude, I decided to not pursue getting approved to sell their funds. - Maybe they should have sent the kool-ade to me chlled!

Jan 12, 2009 6:00 pm

Any opinions on DFA’s new tax aware core funds (TA US Core Equity Portfolio DFTCX) and (TA World ex US Core Equity Portfolio DFTWX). Apparently DFA considers these there best and most efficiently designed products.



Jan 12, 2009 6:28 pm
Harry:

Any opinions on DFA’s new tax aware core funds (TA US Core Equity Portfolio DFTCX) and (TA World ex US Core Equity Portfolio DFTWX). Apparently DFA considers these there best and most efficiently designed products.

  DFA blows.
Jan 12, 2009 6:50 pm

Snaggletooth:



Interesting response…Is that all you’ve got or can you back up your opinion with actual facts?



Jan 12, 2009 8:20 pm
Harry:

Snaggletooth:

Interesting response…Is that all you’ve got or can you back up your opinion with actual facts?

  Yes, I can back it up with several factual points based on research.  But it would be a waste of my time to do it.  I'm sure you can figure it out though.
Jan 13, 2009 1:20 am

Snaggletooth



Well now. My first day on this forum and I come across a senior member who calls himself “snaggletooth” He claims that “DFA Blows”, hold on…it gets better. He than claims he can back up his statement with facts but he doesn’t want to because it would be a waist of his time. Let me guess, Mr. snaggletooth is an advisor that was not approved for access to DFA funds and is now on a mission to disparage one of the most highly regarded mutual fund families in existence. Of course he could defend himself by posting the facts he claims to have, but something tells me that he wont.

Jan 13, 2009 1:27 am

Being "approved" to sell a particular investment or "invited" to invest doesn't seem to carry the same weight as it used to.  Thanks Bernie.

Jan 13, 2009 1:42 am

I hope you are not serious regarding the “most highly regarded mutual fund family”… This stuff is terrible… nice idea, worked for a bit, terrible now… The guys who headed this fund company screwed up somewhere else(Hedge fund or something) DFA was the most overrated stuff ever…

Jan 13, 2009 3:33 am

[quote=Squash1]I hope you are not serious regarding the “most highly regarded mutual fund family”… This stuff is terrible… nice idea, worked for a bit, terrible now… The guys who headed this fund company screwed up somewhere else(Hedge fund or something) DFA was the most overrated stuff ever…[/quote]
Do your homework.  Google "Long Term capital Management."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management

This was a failure of unprecedented proportions (at the time - pre TARP).  Check out the principals & board members of LTCM & the principals/board members of DFA.  Many of the same “geniuses,”  with their Nobel Prizes and all.  They thought their sh*t didn’t stink back then; they think the same thing now. Geniuses?

“Approved” to sell their funds?!  “Approved!?!”  That’s sort of like the politicians saying they “approved” this message.  So bleeping what?!  Wake up, sheeple!

Fool me once, shame on you.  Fool me twice, shame on me.

Jan 13, 2009 4:17 am
Harry:

Snaggletooth

Well now. My first day on this forum and I come across a senior member who calls himself “snaggletooth” He claims that “DFA Blows”, hold on…it gets better. He than claims he can back up his statement with facts but he doesn’t want to because it would be a waist of his time. Let me guess, Mr. snaggletooth is an advisor that was not approved for access to DFA funds and is now on a mission to disparage one of the most highly regarded mutual fund families in existence. Of course he could defend himself by posting the facts he claims to have, but something tells me that he wont.

  You are so wrong.  I wouldn't touch DFA funds with a 10 foot pole.  What makes you think they are "one of the most highly regarded mutual fund families in existence"?  That statement was laughable at best.
Jan 14, 2009 12:23 am

Long Term Capitol Management was a highly leveraged hedge fund that used trading strategy that bare no similarity what so ever to any DFA funds especially the Core funds referenced earlier.



But hay…you don’t to drink the Kool-Aid or agree with financial experts on the caliber of William J. Bernstein who believes that DFA will deliver the performance of capital markets and increase returns through state-of-the-art portfolio design and trading.



Ok…so how do you invest? How do you and the others on this forum capture or beat the market’s returns. Are you stock pickers, active traders, use ETF’s or low cost Vanguard Funds?



Jan 14, 2009 12:56 am
Harry:


Ok…so how do you invest? How do you and the others on this forum capture or beat the market’s returns. Are you stock pickers, active traders, use ETF’s or low cost Vanguard Funds?

  Since when does everyone have to beat the market?  Maybe some of us get paid not to beat the market, but to have a plan for whatever the market does.
Jan 14, 2009 1:33 am

[quote=Harry]Long Term Capitol Management was a highly leveraged hedge fund that used trading strategy that bare no similarity what so ever to any DFA funds especially the Core funds referenced earlier.
[/quote]
Oh, that’s entirely different then, is it?  Except that it’s run by the same geniuses that ran LTCM into the ground at 120 mph.  You will probably be first in line to throw your clients’ money at Bernie Madoff when he gets out of jail too, when he sayshe’ll adopt a less “highly leveraged” strategy then, too. 


[quote=Harry]But hay…you don’t to drink the Kool-Aid or agree with financial experts on the caliber of William J. Bernstein who believes that DFA will deliver the performance of capital markets and increase returns through state-of-the-art portfolio design and trading.
[/quote]
The “caliber” of Bernstein?  Still drinking the “financial experts” kool-aid?  What cave have you been living in the last year or so?  If all these smart “experts” say the DFA PhDs can consistently outperform the markets, who are we morons to argue with them?    We are not worthy!!

Have you checked out the DFA perfomance lately, Einstein?  I’m sure all their shareholders who have lost so much money are so relieved to know what William J. Bernstein thinks, or that the people who were losing them money had higher IQs than them. 


Keep your eye on the ball, lad.

Feb 2, 2009 6:14 pm

www.beaconinvesting.com

www.symmetrypartners.com www.loringward.com      
Feb 2, 2009 8:00 pm

Great stuff. Thanks.

Feb 3, 2009 5:34 am

To get an idea of how great the dfa funds work in various allocation models visit www.indexfunds.com - it’s a DFA approved firm (IFA) that lost their clients about 45% last year.  The problem isn’t the funds - it’s the flawed concept of buy and hold.  Using the DFA funds bactested data and selling out each month end that they fall below their 200 day SMA would increase the returns by nearly 2% while decreasing the standard deviation by 1/3.  This can be backtested nearly 75 years with data from the indexfunds.com site.  I think Snaggle is right - maybe they should name a prestigous university after him:

  The Snaggletooth School of Business...I'd enroll!   fyi - this is a compliment snaggle, DFA does blow.
Mar 19, 2009 1:11 am

DFA should be used with and active strategy, if you are at an independent B/D this can be done using 2 a/c’s.

Maybe you blow???